We need a rule
Growing up, I had a friend, whose mother had a "sewing room" where ostensibly she sewed; her sewing machine did in fact sometimes turn out clothing (much to my friend's consternation, preferring, as we all did back then, brand name clothes). This room, though, also served as a catch-all room for items that otherwise had no place in the house. "Where should I put this thing you bought at the garage sale." Answer: Oh, I thought I could paint this and turn it into a centerpiece for the dining room; just put it in the sewing room for now. What about these Life magazines from the 50s? "They'll be worth money some day; for now, just stack them in the sewing room." Etc.
My parents had no such room, nor would have allowed such a room (except for possibly certain garages). Our homes (and there were many) were always very "put together" -- ensemble furniture, no clutter, decorative accessorizing, etc. My mother insisted that this order be maintained even in our rooms, and I spent many a Friday night during my teen years contemplating the sin of not having cleaned my room for the cleaning lady on Thursday.
In many ways, then, it is not surprising that age 38 found me living like those ladies with 85 cats, nor is it surprising that living that way depressed me and that I have no desire to go back to that. I don't want to live with mismatched furniture, just because it was free. I don't want to live with crap piled on every available surface; I don't want to live with boxes that haven't been unpacked since the last century.
I do not. And I will not. To that end, I rid myself of a half ton of crap that had been cluttering my apartment and my life. Except for books, the majority of what made the cut were kitchen items, clothes (which I'd also pared down significantly; I mean, am I really ever going to fit into that size 1 shirt again?)
Today, Tom said something that nearly made me cry. "I'm waiting for you to get your stuff out of the way so that I can bring over my 45 boxes from my mom's." Seriously, even thinking about it now depresses me. Damn it. I want boxes emptied, so that we can live in a nice, clean, relatively clutter-free house, and he wants to bring over stuff that we don't need, and he hasn't even used in years, like "little, tiny screwdrivers." We don't NEED little, tiny screwdrivers. In fact, I think the whole of Lowe's and Home Depot exists in the house. "I'm not just going to get rid of it," he said. To which I replied, "Why not?"
All I want is a rule. Or two. 1) No redundant systems or solutions. If we already have one, we don't need another. 2) If it isn't a utilitarian or entertaining object that will be employed or enjoyed, it gets tossed (or proactively, it never makes it in). This was the logic I applied to my own purge (and continues to be applied as I continue to unpack); I see no reason why this logic cannot be applied globally. The exceptions to either of these rules is if something is irreplaceable, and it isn't immediately clear if it will be utilized or enjoyed. I would expect these exceptions to be minimal, and that their entertainment and utilitarian value is re-assessed at a point in the mid-future. Exceptions can also be made for items with true sentimental value. Little tiny screwdrivers, therefore, would not make the cut.
This isn't about control. This isn't about being in charge. This is about order. This is about stamping out uncontrolled chaos. This is about our home being a haven.
Is that such a bad thing?

Submitted by ricket
at 6/17/2008 3:17:35 AM- I grew up in a house with just such a sewing room (we used the same name, even). I didn't particularly care for it or the clutter elsewhere in our house. Most of all, I was uncomfortable having guests over. It kind of gave me panic attacks. (pets and younger siblings sometimes exacerbated matters for my teen angst) That said, I still struggle to overcome the clutter. But since the effort usually feels futile, some days I just give up and let leisure rule. I also don't want housekeeping to engulf insane amounts of my time. I still have guests over, but only the ones that have bigger clutter problems than me. No more panic attacks. :)
As for the little, tiny screwdrivers: don't sweat the small stuff. It's small, after all. Just be thankful he doesn't collect motorcycles or engine blocks and the accompanying tools. Then you'd be thrilled to have a tiny set of screwdrivers. Plus, little, tiny screwdrivers are great for fixing sunglasses and fishing out the random miniature screw on the back of a remote. I use my set constantly. (I still have a set of dental tools for the same reason)

Submitted by christy
at 6/17/2008 9:35:54 AM- Thank you, Flipmeister, that is a very constructive idea.
Ricket: when Tom reads your comment and uses it against me, I'm going to hold you personally responsible for everything in each of those 45 boxes. ;-)
JO: Only 30 feet? Records, I can live with (despite the fact that we don't have a turntable); I can even live with books (that's funny, see), but little miscellaneous crap? Nuh-uh.
Kathy: That is the very thing I'm hoping to avoid. And god, the thought of my mother-in-law dying and then Tom lugging all of her stuff to my basement???? I think I'm going to have nightmares for a week, now.

Submitted by Sugared Harpy
at 6/17/2008 10:54:35 AM- I'm watching you two and learning, learning. The boyfriend and I are loosely talking of buying a house and moving in together. Loosely. Luckily, his current house is not cluttered, nor is his basement. BUT he's widowed, and I wonder how much of her stuff will come along...


















DH and I have different ideas about how much "clutter" is acceptable. His tolerance level is much higher than mine is.
When his great aunt died a couple of years ago (she had no children), he inherited about a dozen boxes of pictures and slides. It's not my job to go through them, but he'll only do it when coerced. We still have boxes two layers deep on a table in the basement. I try not to look at them when I walk by.